🏙 New York — Hospital Safety Ratings

Best Hospitals in Buffalo, NY

Compare all 7 Medicare-certified hospitals in Buffalo by official CMS safety score, patient experience, and emergency availability. Data updated 2024.

Hospitals

4.6

Avg Score

With ER

5-Star CMS

Birth Friendly

All 7 Hospitals in Buffalo, NY — Ranked by Safety Score

Upstate New York Va Healthcare System (Western Ny Va Healthcare System)

📍 3495 Bailey Avenue, 14215

🚨 ER ★ 4-Star

5.5
C

Kaleida Health

📍 100 High Street, 14210

🚨 ER 👶 Birth

4.9
D

Sisters Of Charity Hospital

📍 2157 Main Street, 14214

🚨 ER 👶 Birth

4.9
D

Buffalo Psychiatric Center

📍 400 Forest Ave, 14213

4.5
D

Brylin Hosp

📍 1263 Delaware Ave, 14209

4.5
D

Mercy Hospital Of Buffalo

📍 565 Abbott Road, 14220

🚨 ER 👶 Birth

4.3
D

Erie County Medical Center

📍 462 Grider Street, 14215

🚨 ER

3.3
F

Best Hospitals in Buffalo, NY — 2025 Guide

Buffalo has 7 Medicare-certified hospitals. The top-rated facility is Upstate New York Va Healthcare System (Western Ny Va Healthcare System) with a Safety Score of 5.5/10. The city average of 4.6/10 is below the national average. Of 7 hospitals, 5 provide emergency services.

Safety scores are based on official CMS Medicare data, updated 2024. For more information on how to choose a hospital, read our Hospital Selection Guide.

⚠️ Medical Disclaimer: This content is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a licensed U.S. healthcare provider for personal medical decisions. In an emergency, call 911 immediately. Data source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), 2024.